Burns
Volume 38, Issue 1 , Pages 6-18 , February 2012

A systematic review of the quality of burn scar rating scales for clinical and research use

  • Zephanie Tyack

      Affiliations

    • Queensland Health, Central Queensland Health Services District, Queensland, Australia
    • School of Medicine, The University of Queensland, St Lucia, Queensland, Australia
    • Corresponding Author InformationCorresponding author at: Level 2, Allied Health, Rockhampton Base Hospital, Canning St, Rockhampton, Qld 4700, Australia. Tel.: +61 07 4920 7396/0427 462286; fax: +61 07 4920 6539.
    • ,
  • Megan Simons

      Affiliations

    • Department of Occupational Therapy, Royal Children's Hospital, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
    • School of Health & Rehabilitation Sciences, The University of Queensland, St Lucia, Queensland, Australia
    • ,
  • Anneliese Spinks

      Affiliations

    • Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Ecosystem Sciences Division, St Lucia, Queensland, Australia
    • School of Medicine, Griffith University, Meadowbrook, Queensland, Australia
    • ,
  • Jason Wasiak

      Affiliations

    • Victorian Adult Burns Service and School of Public Health and Preventative, Medicine, Monash University, The Alfred Hospital, Commercial Rd, Melbourne, VIC, Australia

,Accepted 21 September 2011.

References 

  1. Bloemen MC, van der Veer WM, Ulrich MM, van Zuijlen PP, Niessen FB, Middelkoop E. Prevention and curative management of hypertrophic scar formation. Burns. 2009;35(4):463–475
  2. McHugh AA, Fowlkes BJ, Maevsky EI, Smith DJ, Rodriguez JL, Garner WL. Biomechanical alterations in normal skin and hypertrophic scar after thermal injury. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1997;18(2):104–108
  3. Moore P, Moore M, Blakeney P, Meyer W, Murphy L, Herndon D. Competence and physical impairment of pediatric survivors of burns of more than 80% total body surface area. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1996;17(6 Pt 1):547–551
  4. Richard R, Steinlage R, Staley M, Keck T. Mathematic model to estimate change in burn scar length required for joint range of motion. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1996;17(5):436–443[discussion 435]
  5. Martin D, Umraw N, Gomez M, Cartotto R. Changes in subjective vs objective burn scar assessment over time: does the patient agree with what we think?. J Burn Care Rehabil. 2003;24(4):239–244
  6. Engrav LH, Garner WL, Tredget EE. Hypertrophic scar, wound contraction and hyper-hypopigmentation. J Burn Care Res. 2007;28(4):593–597
  7. Sullivan T, Smith J, Kermode J, McIver E, Courtemanche DJ. Rating the burn scar. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1990;11:256–260
  8. Draaijers LJ, Tempelman FR, Botman YA, Tuinebreijer WE, Middelkoop E, Kreis RW, et al. The Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale: a reliable and feasible tool for scar evaluation. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2004;113(7):1960–1965
  9. Oliveira GV, Chinkes D, Mitchell C, Oliveras G, Hawkins HK, Herndon DN. Objective assessment of burn scar vascularity, erythema, pliability, thickness, and planimetry. Dermatol Surg. 2005;31(1):48–58
  10. Bray R, Forrester K, Leonard C, McArthur R, Tulip J, Lindsay R. Laser Doppler imaging of burn scars: a comparison of wavelength and scanning methods. Burns. 2003;29(3):199–206
  11. Davey RB, Sprod RT, Neild TO. Computerised colour: a technique for the assessment of burn scar hypertrophy. A preliminary report. Burns. 1999;25(3):207–213
  12. Draaijers LJ, Tempelman FR, Botman YA, Kreis RW, Middelkoop E, van Zuijlen PP. Colour evaluation in scars: tristimulus colorimeter, narrow-band simple reflectance meter or subjective evaluation?. Burns. 2004;30(2):103–107
  13. Lye I, Edgar DW, Wood FM, Carroll S. Tissue tonometry is a simple, objective measure for pliability of burn scar: is it reliable?. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(1):82–85
  14. Spann K, Mileski WJ, Atiles L, Purdue G, Hunt J. The 1996 Clinical Research Award Use of a pneumatonometer in burn scar assessment. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1996;17(6 Pt 1):515–517
  15. Nedelec B, Correa JA, Rachelska G, Armour A, LaSalle L. Quantitative measurement of hypertrophic scar: intrarater reliability, sensitivity, and specificity. J Burn Care Res. 2008;29(3):489–500
  16. Brusselaers N, Pirayesh A, Hoeksema H, Verbelen J, Blot S, Monstrey S. Burn scar assessment: a systematic review of objective scar assessment tools. Burns. 2010;36(8):1157–1164
  17. Durani P, McGrouther DA, Ferguson MW. Current scales for assessing human scarring: a review. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2009;62(6):713–720
  18. Portney LG, Watkins MP. Foundations of clinical research: applications to practice. New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall; 2009;
  19. Streiner DL, Norman GR. Health measurement scales: a practical guide to their development and use. 4th ed.. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2008;
  20. McDowell I, Measuring Health: . A guide to rating scales and questionnaires. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2006;
  21. Terwee CB, Bot SDM, Boer MR, van der Windt DAWM, Knol DL, Dekker J, et al. Quality criteria were proposed for measurement properties of health status questionnaires. J Clin Epidemiol. 2007;60:34–42
  22. Stinson JN, Kavanagh T, Yamada J, Gill N, Stevens B. Systematic review of the psychometric properties, interpretability and feasibility of self-report pain intensity measures for use in clinical trials in children and adolescents. Pain. 2006;125:143–157
  23. Scientific Advisory Committee of the Medical Outcomes Trust . Assessing health status and quality-of-life instruments: attributes and review criteria. Qual Life Res. 2002;11:193–205
  24. Albers G, Echteld MA, deVet HCW, Onwuteaka-Philipsen BD, Van derLinden MHM, Deliens L. Evaluation of quality-of-life measures for use in palliative care: a systematic review. Palliat Med. 2010;24(1):17–37
  25. Fleiss JL. Statistical methods for rates and proportions. New York: Wiley; 1981;
  26. Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics. 1977;33:159–174
  27. Husted JA, Cook RJ, Farewell VT, Gladman DD. Methods of assessing responsiveness: a critical review and recommendations. J Clin Epidemiol. 2000;53:459–468
  28. de Vet HCW, Terwee CB, Bouter LM. Clinimetrics and psychometrics: two sides of the same coin. J Clin Epidemiol; 56, 1146–1147.
  29. Higgins JPT, Green S. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell; 2008;
  30. Akita S, Akino K, Imaizumi T, Tanaka K, Anraku K, Yano H, et al. The quality of pediatric burn scars is improved by early administration of basic fibroblast growth factor. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(3):333–338
  31. Akita S, Akino K, Imaizumi T, Hirano A. Basic fibroblast growth factor accelerates and improves second-degree burn wound healing. Wound Repair Regen. 2008;16(5):635–641
  32. Crowe JM, Simpson K, Johnson W, Allen J. Reliability of photographic analysis in determining change in scar appearance. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1998;19(2):83–86
  33. Vloemans AF, Soesman AM, Suijker M, Kreis RW, Middelkoop E. A randomised clinical trial comparing a hydrocolloid-derived dressing and glycerol preserved allograft skin in the management of partial thickness burns. Burns. 2003;29(7):702–710
  34. Omranifard M, Rasti M. Comparing the effects of conventional method, pulsed dye laser and erbium laser for the treatment of hypertrophic scars in Iranian patients. J Res Med Sci. 2007;121(6):277–281
  35. Wang ZY, Zhang J, Lu SL. Objective evaluation of burn and post-surgical scars and the accuracy of subjective scar type judgment. Chin Med J (Engl). 2008;121(24):2517–2520
  36. Zhang Y, Goldgof DB, Sarkar S, Tsap LV. A modeling approach for burn scar assessment using natural features and elastic property. IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 2004;23(10):1325–1329
  37. Widgerow AD, Chait LA, Stals PJ, Stals R, Candy G. Multimodality scar management program. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2009;33(4):533–543
  38. Monstrey S, Beele H, Kettler M, Van Landuyt K, Blondeel P, Matton G, et al. Allogeneic cultured keratinocytes vs. cadaveric skin to cover wide-mesh autogenous split-thickness skin grafts. Ann Plast Surg. 1999;43(3):268–272
  39. Kono T, Erçöçen AR, Nakazawa H, Nozaki M. Treatment of hypertrophic scars using a long-pulsed dye laser with cryogen-spray cooling. Ann Plast Surg. 2005;54(5):487–493
  40. Sheridan RL, Choucair RJ. Acellular allogenic dermis does not hinder initial engraftment in burn wound resurfacing and reconstruction. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1997;18(6):496–499
  41. Wood F, Liddiard K, Skinner A, Ballentyne J. Scar management of cultured epithelial autograft. Burns. 1996;22(6):451–454
  42. Lee SM, Ngim CK, Chan YY, Ho MJ. A comparison of Sil-K and Epiderm in scar management. Burns. 1996;22(6):483–487
  43. Clark JA, Leung KS, Cheng JC, Leung PC. The hypertrophic scar and microcirculation properties. Burns. 1996;22(6):447–450
  44. Clark JA, Cheng JC, Leung KS. Mechanical properties of normal skin and hypertrophic scars. Burns. 1996;22(6):43–46
  45. Madden MR, LaBruna AA, Hajjar DP, Staiano-Coico L. Transplantation of cryopreserved cultured epidermal allografts. J Trauma. 1996;40(5):743–750
  46. Hambleton J, Shakespeare PG, Pratt BJ. The progress of hypertrophic scars monitored by ultrasound measurements of thickness. Burns. 1992;18:301–307
  47. Samies J, Gehling M. Acoustic pressure wound therapy for management of mixed partial- and full-thickness burns in a rural wound center. Ostomy Wound Manage. 2008;54(3):56–59
  48. Erol OO, Gurlek A, Agaoglu G, Topcuoglu E, Oz H. Treatment of hypertrophic scars and keloids using intense pulsed light (IPL). Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2008;32(6):902–909
  49. Truong PT, Lee JC, Soer B, Gaul CA, Olivotto IA. Reliability and validity testing of the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale in evaluating linear scars after breast cancer surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;119(2):487–494
  50. Selvaggi G, Boeckx W, De Wulf M, Van den Kerckhove E. Late results of burn wound scar after cerium nitrate–silver sulfadiazine and compressive therapy: scanning electron microscopy evaluation of a keloid scar. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;119(6):1965–1967
  51. Rennekampff HO, Rabbels J, Reinhard V, Becker ST, Schaller HE. Comparing the Vancouver Scar Scale with the cutometer in the assessment of donor site wounds treated with various dressings in a randomized trial. J Burn Care Res. 2006;27(3):345–351
  52. Du YC, Lin CM, Chen YF, Chen CL, Chen T. Implementation of a burn scar assessment system by ultrasound techniques. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2006;1:2328–2331
  53. Cubison TC, Pape SA, Parkhouse N. Evidence for the link between healing time and the development of hypertrophic scars (HTS) in paediatric burns due to scald injury. Burns. 2006;32(8):992–999
  54. Van den Kerckhove E, Stappaerts K, Fieuws S, Laperre J, Massage P, Flour M, et al. The assessment of erythema and thickness on burn related scars during pressure garment therapy as a preventive measure for hypertrophic scarring. Burns. 2005;31(6):696–702
  55. van de Kar A, Corion LUM, Smeulders MJ, Draaijers LJ, van der Horst CMAM, van Zuijlen PPM. Reliable and feasible evaluation of linear scars by the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2005;116(2):514–522
  56. Akita S, Akino K, Imaizumi T, Hirano A. A basic fibroblast growth factor improved the quality of skin grafting in burn patients. Burns. 2005;31(7):855–858
  57. Li-Tsang CW, Lau JC, Liu SK. Validation of an objective scar pigmentation measurement by using a spectrocolorimeter. Burns. 2003;29(8):779–784
  58. Palao R, Gomez P, Huguet P. Burned breast reconstructive surgery with Integra dermal regeneration template. Br J Plast Surg. 2003;56(3):252–259
  59. Van den Kerckhove E, Staes F, Flour M, Stappaerts K, Boeckx W. Reproducibility of repeated measurements on post-burn scars with Dermascan C. Skin Res Technol. 2003;9(1):81–84
  60. Allison KP, Kiernan MN, Waters RA, Clement RM. Pulsed dye laser treatment of burn scars Alleviation or irritation?. Burns. 2003;29(3):207–213
  61. Gohari S, Gambla C, Healey M, Spaulding G, Gordon KB, Swan J, et al. Evaluation of tissue-engineered skin (human skin substitute) and secondary intention healing in the treatment of full thickness wounds after Mohs micrographic or excisional surgery. Dermatol Surg. 2002;28(12):1107–1114
  62. Atiyeh BS, Ioannovich J, Al-Amm CA, El-Musa KA, Dham R. Improving scar quality: a prospective clinical study. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2002;26(6):470–476
  63. van den Kerckhove E, Stappaerts KHM, Boeckx WD, Staes F, Van den Hof B, Monstrey S, et al. The influence of different occlusive plates on the erythema of hypertrophic burn scars. Eur J Plast Surg. 2001;24(4):182–185
  64. Cheng W, Saing H, Zhou H, Han Y, Peh W, Tam PK. Ultrasound assessment of scald scars in Asian children receiving pressure garment therapy. J Pediatr Surg. 2001;36(3):466–469
  65. Singer AJ, Thode HC, McClain SA. Development of a histomorphologic scale to quantify cutaneous scars after burns. Acad Emerg Med. 2000;7(10):1083–1088
  66. Goldwyn RM. Bridging the gap: the 34th Varaztad H. Kazanjian Memorial Lecture. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2007;120(6):1722–1728
  67. Beausang E, Floyd H, Dunn KW, Orton CI, Ferguson MW. A new quantitative scale for clinical scar assessment. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998;102(6):1954–1961
  68. Quinn JV, Drzewiecki AE, Stiell IG, Elmslie TJ. Appearance scales to measure cosmetic outcomes of healed lacerations. Am J Emerg Med. 1995;13(2):229–231
  69. Kerrigan CL, Homa K. Visual assessment of linear scars: a new tool. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2009;124(5):1513–1519
  70. de Oliveira GV, Sanford AP, Murphy KD, de Oliveira HM, Wilkins JP, Wu X, et al. Growth hormone effects on hypertrophic scar formation: a randomized controlled trial of 62 burned children. Wound Repair Regen. 2004;12(4):404–411
  71. Silverberg R, Johnson J, Moffat M. The effects of soft tissue mobilization on the immature burn scar: results of a pilot study. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1996;17(3):252–259
  72. Esposito G, Ziccardi P, Scioli M, Pappone N, Scuderi N. The use of a modified tonometer in burn scar therapy. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1990;11:86–89
  73. Donati L. Invited commentary: the influence of different occlusive plates on the erythema of hypertrophic burn scars, by E. van den Kerckhove. Eur J Plast Surg. 2001;24:186
  74. Rab M, Koller R, Ruzicka M, Burda G, Kamolz LP, Bierochs B, et al. Should dermal scald burns in children be covered with autologous skin grafts or with allogeneic cultivated keratinocytes? – “The Viennese Concept”. Burns. 2005;31:578–586
  75. Stewart CJ, Frank R, Forrester KR, Tulip J, Lindsay R, Bray RC. A comparison of two laser-based methods for determination of burn scar perfusion: Laser Doppler versus Laser Speckle Imaging. Burns. 2005;31(6):744–752
  76. Idriss N, Maibach HI. Scar assessment scales: a dermatologic overview. Skin Res Technol. 2009;15(1):1–5
  77. van Zuijlen PP, Vloemans JF, van Trier AJ, Suijker MH, van Unen E, Groenevelt F, et al. Dermal substitution in acute burns and reconstructive surgery: a subjective and objective long-term follow-up. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001;108(7):938–1946
  78. Falder S, Browne A, Edgar D, Staples E, Fong J, Rea S, et al. Core outcomes for adult burn survivors: a clinical overview. Burns. 2009;35(5):618–641
  79. Nedelec B, Correa JA, Rachelska G, Armour A, LaSalle L. Quantitative measurement of hypertrophic scar: interrater reliability and concurrent validity. J Burn Care Res. 2008;29(3):501–511
  80. Schwanholt CA, Ridgway CL, Greenhalgh DG, Staley MJ, Gaboury TJ, Morress CS, et al. A prospective study of burn scar maturation in pediatrics: does age matter?. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1994;15(5):416–420
  81. Branski LK, Herndon DN, Pereira C, Mlcak RP, Celis MM, Lee JO, et al. Longitudinal assessment of Integra in primary burn management: a randomized pediatric clinical trial. Crit Care Med. 2007;35(11):2615–2623
  82. Harte D, Gordon J, Shaw M, Stinson M, Porter-Armstrong A. The use of pressure and silicone in hypertrophic scar management in burns patients: a pilot randomized controlled trial. J Burn Care Res. 2009;30(4):632–642
  83. Baryza MJ, Baryza GA. The Vancouver Scar Scale: an administrative tool and its inter-rater reliability. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1995;16:535–538
  84. Forbes-Duchart L, Marshall S, Strock A, Cooper JE. Determination of inter-rater reliability in pediatric burn scar assessment using a modified version of the Vancouver Scar Scale. J Burn Care Res. 2007;28(3):460–467
  85. Fraulin FO, Illmayer SJ, Tredget EE. Assessment of cosmetic and functional results of conservative versus surgical management of facial burns. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1996;17(1):19–29
  86. Tredget EE, Shankowsky HA, Pannu R, Nedelec B, Iwashina T, Ghahary A, et al. Transforming growth factor-beta in thermally injured patients with hypertrophic scars: effects of interferon alpha-2b. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998;102(5):1317–1328
  87. Nedelec B, Shankowsky HA, Tredget EE. Rating the resolving hypertrophic scar: comparison of the Vancouver Scar Scale and scar volume. J Burn Care Rehabil. 2000;21(3):205–212
  88. Yeong EK, Mann R, Engrav LH, Goldberg M, Cain V, Costa B, et al. Improved burn scar assessment with use of a new scar-rating scale. J Burn Care Rehabil. 1997;18(4):353–355
  89. Fong SS, Hung LK, Cheng JC. The cutometer and ultrasonography in the assessment of postburn hypertrophic scar – a preliminary study. Burns. 1997;23(Suppl 1):S12–S18
  90. Masters M, McMahon M, Svens B. Reliability testing of a new scar assessment tool Matching Assessment of Scars and Photographs (MAPS). J Burn Care Rehabil. 2005;26(3):273–284
  91. Moiemen NS, Vlachou E, Staiano JJ, Thawy Y, Frame JD. Reconstructive surgery with Integra dermal regeneration template: histologic study clinical evaluation, and current practice. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;117(7S):160S–174S
  92. Draaijers LJ, Botman YA, Tempelman FR, Kreis RW, Middelkoop E, van Zuijlen PP. Skin elasticity meter or subjective evaluation in scars: a reliability assessment. Burns. 2004;30:109–114
  93. Forbes-Duchart L, Cooper J, Nedelec B, Ross L, Quanbury A. Burn therapists’ opinion on the application and essential characteristics of a burn scar outcome measure. J Burn Care Res. 2009;30(5):792–800
  94. Jarrett M, McMahon M, Stiller K. Physical outcomes of patients with burn injuries – a 12 month follow-up. J Burn Care Res. 2008;29(6):975–984
  95. Musgrave MA, Umraw N, Fish JS, Gomez M, Cartotto RC. The effect of silicone gel sheets on perfusion of hypertrophic burn scars. J Burn Care Rehabil. 2002;23(3):208–214
  96. Chou TD, Chen SL, Lee TW, Chen SG, Cheng TY, Lee CH, et al. Reconstruction of burn scar of the upper extremities with artificial skin. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001;108(2):378–384
  97. Lau JCM, Li-Tsang CWP, Zheng YP. Application of tissue ultrasound palpation system (TUPS) in objective scar evaluation. Burns. 2005;31(4):445–452
  98. Richard RL. OT/PT editorial. J Burn Care Rehabil. 2005;26(3):272
  99. Verhaegan PDHM, van der Wal MBA, Middelkoop E, van Zuijlen PPM. Objective scar assessment tools: a clinimetric appraisal. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2011;127(4):1561–1570

PII: S0305-4179(11)00307-X

doi: 10.1016/j.burns.2011.09.021

Burns
Volume 38, Issue 1 , Pages 6-18 , February 2012

Article Tools